Skip to main contentAccessibility feedback
heart
URGENT: Time is running out—our campaign ends May 17! If Catholic.com has helped you, please help keep it free for millions. We are $7,000 away from hitting our $20,000 match. Please donate today.
Has catholic.com helped you? Donations matched up to $20,000.
Give NowGive Now
Get 20 Answers: The Papacy Free.

What is the anthropic principle?

Listen to the audio version of this content

Question:

What is the anthropic principle?

Answer:

Some atheists say we shouldn’t be surprised the physical laws of the universe (such as the strength of gravity) are fine-tuned for life, because if they weren’t, we wouldn’t be here to appreciate that fact. These critics say a finely tuned universe is “necessary” because of an anthropic coincidence: we shouldn’t be surprised that we observe a life-permitting universe because those are the only kind of universes we would observe.

The anthropic principle does explain why we don’t observe life-prohibiting universes (because we’d be nonexistent). However, it doesn’t explain why we observe such an incredibly unlikely life-permitting universe. To borrow an example from John Leslie, that would be like saying we shouldn’t be surprised fifty trained marksmen shot me and all of them missed, because if even one of them had killed me, I wouldn’t be here to appreciate that fact.

Just as there must be a reason the entire firing squad missed, there must be a reason that the universe is so improbably fine-tuned for intelligent life.

Did you like this content? Please help keep us ad-free
Enjoying this content?  Please support our mission!Donatewww.catholic.com/support-us
By continuing to use this site you agree to our Terms and that you have read our Privacy Policy.