How Many Apostles Were There?

March 12, 2014 | 4 comments

There were twelve apostles, right?

Actually, it’s more complicated than that.

An initial complication is the fact that Judas Iscariot died and was replaced by Matthias (Acts 1:12-26).

You could look at that and say, “Okay, there were thirteen apostles, total, but only twelve at one time.”

What about Paul?

Some (at least some in the Protestant community) have suggested that, since the New Testament doesn’t record Matthias as having done anything, his election wasn’t valid, and Paul was Judas’s real replacement—again allowing for the total to be only twelve at one time.

This is a bad argument, though.

 

Why It’s Bad

First, the New Testament does not present Matthias’s election as invalid. It presents it in a straight-forward way with the ultimate conclusion that Matthias “was enrolled with the eleven apostles” (Acts 1:26).

Second, the New Testament does not have to record an apostle as having “done something” for him to be an apostle. The New Testament records next to nothing—or, depending on how you identify different biblical figures—it even records nothing at all about what some of the apostles did. Yet it explicitly names them as apostles.

Third, if the New Testament does not record Matthias as having done anything, the Church Fathers do. For example, Eusebius records that Matthias was noted for preaching self-control to avoid sexual immorality. According to Eusebius:

But they say that Matthias also taught in the same manner that we ought to fight against and abuse the flesh, and not give way to it for the sake of pleasure, but strengthen the soul by faith and knowledge [Ecclesiastical History III:29].

Fourth, if the claim were to be made on Protestant premises then it would have to be defensible by sola scriptura—the claim that we should be able to prove theological points “by Scripture alone.” Yet there seems to be no place in Scripture requiring there to be only twelve living apostles.

Instead, the New Testament treats both Matthias and Paul as valid apostles.

 

Not of the Twelve

The logical way to look at Paul, therefore, is that he was a valid apostle but not one of “the Twelve.”

The New Testament never refers to him as one of the Twelve apostles.

He was ordained to ministry, in Acts 13, in Antioch, not by the apostles in Jerusalem, as Matthias was.

And he was not a witness of the ministry of Jesus in the way that Matthias was. Peter made it clear that this was a requirement for being one of the Twelve:

So one of the men who have accompanied us during all the time that the Lord Jesus went in and out among us,beginning from the baptism of John until the day when he was taken up from us—one of these men must become with us a witness to his resurrection [Acts 1:21-22].

We thus see that the Twelve were a distinct group that accompanied Jesus during his earthly ministry and who served as witnesses of this and his resurrection.

Paul did not become a follower of Jesus until after the Ascension, so he could not belong to the Twelve.

He did, however, have an apparition of Jesus (he calls it a vision in Acts 26:19), in which he was called to be an apostle, and thus he asks the rhetorical questions: “Am I not free? Am I not an apostle? Have I not seen Jesus our Lord? Are not you my workmanship in the Lord?” (1 Cor. 9:1).

He thus appears to base his call to apostleship on his apparition of Jesus rather than of having been a follower of his during his earthly ministry.

This indicates that there could be apostles beyond the Twelve, who were not witnesses of Christ’s ministry.

Are there any other apostles who weren’t members of the Twelve?

Yes. But we’ll look at them in another post.


Jimmy Akin was born in Texas and grew up nominally Protestant. At age 20 he experienced a profound conversion to Christ. Planning on becoming a Protestant pastor or seminary professor, Jimmy started an intensive study of the Bible, but the more he immersed himself in Scripture, the more he found it to...

The Fathers Know Best: Your Essential Guide to the Teachings of the Early Church
The Fathers Know Best: Your Essential Guide to the Teachings of the Early Church is a unique resource that introduces you to the teachings of the first Christians in a way no other work can. It is specially designed to make it easy for you to find the information you want and need.

Comments by Catholic.com Members

#1  Anne Concienne - Grandview, Washington

I was wondering, in the movie Son of God, Mary Magdalene was shown with the apostles throughout the entire movie. Even at the last supper. Is this accurate? I understood she was at the raising of Lazarus and during the passion, but I didn't think she was there throughout his whole ministry. It shows her even on the boat when Jesus walked on water.

March 13, 2014 at 8:01 am PST
#2  Sensei Mitch - Willington, Connecticut

Awesome site and great explanation! This will come in handy when I am trying to convert my protestant friends!

March 13, 2014 at 12:38 pm PST
#3  Logan Rieck - Albany, Illinois

Anne, I don't believe Mary Magdalene would have been at the Last Supper. Perhaps they were influenced by the vogue idea that Mary Magdalene was the "Beloved Disciple" and not John. But, I've never seen the movie so I can't be sure how they portray her.

Movies take artistic license, this could just be that, the Gospels don't share an awful lot of information concerning her.

March 20, 2014 at 3:04 pm PST
#4  Michael Rogala - Chicago, Illinois

Had a nice comment here that was historically correct and would be accepted in scholarly circles to Jimmy's whatever this was on the apostles/Apostles. Apparently his insecurity got the best of him and erased it . . . so now we are left solely with his poppycock.

Be sure to catch Jimmy's comments on the discussion that certain prayer positions are proprietary to priests. It's a riot and currently in circulation amongst several colleagues for use in seminary and theological forums. Thanks Jimmy . . . you write great material.

August 23, 2014 at 3:13 pm PST

You are not logged in. Login or register to leave a comment.